

February 24, 2023 - PBS NewsHour full episode
2/24/2023 | 57m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
February 24, 2023 - PBS NewsHour full episode
February 24, 2023 - PBS NewsHour full episode
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Major corporate funding for the PBS News Hour is provided by BDO, BNSF, Consumer Cellular, American Cruise Lines, and Raymond James. Funding for the PBS NewsHour Weekend is provided by...

February 24, 2023 - PBS NewsHour full episode
2/24/2023 | 57m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
February 24, 2023 - PBS NewsHour full episode
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch PBS News Hour
PBS News Hour is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipAMNA NAWAZ: Good evening, and welcome.
I'm Amna Nawaz.
GEOFF BENNETT: And I'm Geoff Bennett.
On the "NewsHour" tonight: With renewed resolve, Ukraine marks one year of defending its territory from Russia's brutal invasion.
VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY, Ukrainian President (through translator): I am grateful to everyone who endured last February, this past year, and who gives Ukraine invincibility.
AMNA NAWAZ: Rebuilding after the devastating earthquake that struck Turkey and Syria is hampered by aftershocks, a lack of resources and the sheer scale of destruction.
GEOFF BENNETT: And a new lawsuit from Malcolm X's family could provide answers about who was responsible for his assassination nearly six decades ago.
(BREAK) GEOFF BENNETT: Welcome to the "NewsHour."
Today is the one year is the first anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
It is the largest war in Europe in 80 years, marked by calamitous destruction and death, but also by bravery and the resilient will of the Ukrainians.
AMNA NAWAZ: The somber day was observed around the world, at the United Nations, across Europe and most profoundly in Ukraine.
In Kyiv, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy spoke at length to the world media today, at times welling up with tears for his family and his country.
With the support of the Pulitzer Center, Nick Schifrin reports again tonight from Ukraine.
NICK SCHIFRIN: In the ancient heart of city that has endured one year of war, they sang the national anthem.
It is titled "Ukraine Has Not Yet Perished," a dark, but determined call to stay resilient on a solemn anniversary.
President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, his leadership forged in the fire of war, honored the men and women who have saved the country.
VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY, Ukrainian President (through translator): I am grateful to everyone who endured last February, this past year, and who gives Ukraine invincibility.
NICK SCHIFRIN: There was a moment of silence for lives lost.
Zelenskyy honored grieving widows, and he awarded Ukrainian servicemen with the highest of awards, Hero of Ukraine.
And from a Kyiv basement, Zelenskyy gave a two-and-a-half-hour press conference and recalled for him what was the war's worst moment, the day he visited the sites of some of the war's worst atrocities.
VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY (through translator): Bucha.
I think Bucha.
What I saw the moment we de-occupied Bucha, it was horrible.
What we have seen, the devil is not somewhere below us.
He is among us.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Two days after China's top diplomat visited the Kremlin, today, Beijing released a peace plan that called for respect for territorial integrity, but didn't detail what that meant.
Zelenskyy said today he would oppose the plan if it didn't call for a Russian withdrawal.
VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY (through translator): As far as I know, China has historically respected territorial integrity, and so it should do everything so that the Russian Federation leaves our territory, as it is in this that the gravity of sovereignty and territorial integrity lies.
ANTONY BLINKEN, U.S. Secretary of State: No one wants peace more than the Ukrainian people.
NICK SCHIFRIN: At the U.N. Security Council, Secretary of State Antony Blinken advocated for what the U.S. and Ukraine call a just and durable peace.
ANTONY BLINKEN: For peace to be durable, it must ensure that Russia can't simply rest, rearm, and relaunch the war in a few months or a few years.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Today, the U.S. and other leaders of the seventh largest industrial nations announced new sanctions and export controls on Russia.
The U.S. also unveiled an additional $2 billion worth of military aid, including more ammunition for long-range rockets.
And, on this anniversary, much of the Western world showed solidarity, from Amsterdam, to Sydney, and even in Moscow, memorials on monuments devoted to Ukrainian writers.
But even those flower-bearers were quickly detained.
It is still illegal in Russia to call the war a war.
And a year is a long time to be at war, even for hardened warriors.
VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY (through translator): My children are the most important people for me.
I do not see them often.
My parents, I do not see them at all.
I'm very proud of my wife.
NICK SCHIFRIN: That was Zelenskyy at his most vulnerable.
But he was also today at his most determined.
He ruled out any idea of negotiating with Vladimir Putin and said that the only vision for the end of this war that he could see is Russia's total withdrawal -- Amna, Geoff.
AMNA NAWAZ: Nick Schifrin with another tremendous piece of reporting there.
Nick, we just heard a little bit of what President Zelenskyy had to say today.
That was a two-hour press conference, as you know.
You were there.
What else stood out to you from his remarks?
NICK SCHIFRIN: Zelenskyy's spokesman called on more than 40 reporters across five continents.
There was clearly a desire from his team to get into the markets across from Latin America all the way to East Asia.
On the U.S., he was asked about Americans who are saying to pollsters that they believe the administration is spending too much money to support Ukraine.
And he warned that, if the U.S. did not support Ukraine enough to win over Russia, that Russia would eventually launch a war against NATO, and American soldiers would have to go and fight and die, like Ukrainian soldiers would fight and die, are fighting and dying right now.
And, on China, beyond the peace plan, he said that Beijing must not send weapons to Russia.
He said that was his -- quote -- "number one priority.
I'm doing everything I can to ensure that doesn't happen."
That, of course, is something that the U.S. is also warning Beijing is considering.
GEOFF BENNETT: So, Nick, you have been in Ukraine for the past two weeks.
This is your fourth reporting trip to that country since Russia launched its full-scale invasion last year.
You have interviewed Ukrainian troops.
You have spoken to everyday Ukrainians.
Is there a message that the people you have spoken with want to convey to Americans?
NICK SCHIFRIN: The message is two words: weapons and resilience.
Ukraine needs more weapons in order to launch a counteroffensive in the coming weeks and months.
And that's not only the armored vehicles that the U.S. is sending to try and launch that counteroffensive.
It's also basic ammunition.
I visited multiple units on the front, Geoff, that have said that they are short on ammunition.
And also resilience.
You hear that from Zelenskyy, to the soldier on the front, to the man who has just lost his home in Eastern Ukraine to a Russian rocket.
They are resilient in spite of, but because of all of the horrors, all of the crimes, what the U.S. calls crimes against humanity that I have been reporting on committed by Russian forces who are waging total war.
The person who pushed the button that launched the missile that struck 13 Marat Street, Kramatorsk, almost certainly did not know of the apartments that once stood here, the people and families who once lived here, and the lives that were stolen here.
But 60-year-old Valentina knows.
She might have lived on the fourth floor, but all that she owns fell here in the lobby.
She salvages what she can from the Russian strike on February 1 that Ukraine and the U.S. called indiscriminate.
She walked up to her apartment, despite the frequent air raid siren.
She has lived here longer than Ukraine has been independent.
She was in her apartment when the missile struck.
She is lucky to be alive.
Today, she uses it for storage.
This is what remains of her possessions.
The wall that used to have a window into the bathroom is now a window onto the ground below.
That's her bathtub, and the aqua tiles installed by her and her son.
VALENTINA, Resident of Kramatorsk, Ukraine (through translator): I was asleep.
And I was lucky that I was on the other side of the apartment.
Had I been sleeping on the side, you see for yourself.
NICK SCHIFRIN: So, that's your son.
She shows me videos of her son.
In 2014, he went to fight following Russia's initial invasion.
He never came back.
VALENTINA (through translator): On March 23, he would have been 44.
My life has been lived.
For 60 years, I was saving, creating this home, and now it's all gone.
There was a grocery store here.
And they got me some groceries, just strangers, total strangers.
This was the first year they have opened the store.
They called me and asked: "Do you need anything?"
I said: "I have never asked anyone for anything my whole life.
I'm very ashamed.
But I don't have anything."
And they got me groceries.
They said: "This is for you from our family."
That's it.
Everybody left.
I'm here all alone.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Artem Shalata is a Donetsk region war crimes prosecutor who is investigating the strike he calls a violation of the rules of war.
ARTEM SHALATA, Donetsk Region War Crimes Prosecutor (through translator): During this attack, a married couple died.
A 61-year-old woman and her 31-year-old daughter died.
And 17 people were wounded.
NICK SCHIFRIN: He and his fellow prosecutors visit the aftermath of many strikes, and try to find the Russian missile that can be sometimes be linked with specific units.
And they document graves of the Ukrainians whom Russians have killed with overwhelming regularity.
What is the scale of Russian crimes in Donetsk?
ARTEM SHALATA: We are overseeing investigations of more than 20,000 criminal cases, in connection with violations of the rules of war.
NICK SCHIFRIN: One of the most notorious occurred here, the Kramatorsk train station, where the horror of what happened hangs heavy for even soldiers and the memorial marks the most innocent victims.
Last April 8, hundreds of Ukrainians from the east arrived on the platform and inside the station to try and flee the war.
Suddenly, they flinched.
Human Rights Watch investigated the attack and created this animation.
At that moment, a mile-and-a-half above the station, a Tochka-U cluster bomb 20 feet long with 50 bomblets inside exploded and released its deadly submunitions, each with explosions and metal rings.
When they land, they burst into thousands of fragments and create terror.
At least 58 people died, more than 100 injured, one of the war's deadliest moments.
Left behind, the suitcases that would never be used again, the prized possession that would never be held again.
Apparently, the Russians considered the attack tit for tat.
The missile that landed here was spray-painted "Payback for our children."
IDA SAWYER, Human Rights Watch: I mean, absolutely horrific what they did.
This was a known evacuation point.
We counted over 500 people at this train station at the moment of the attack.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Ida Sawyer directs the Crisis and Conflict Division at Human Rights Watch.
IDA SAWYER: This attack at the train station clearly a violation of the laws of war and an apparent war crime.
These are people desperately fleeing war.
We have seen extensive war crimes, crimes against humanity being committed over the past year.
And it is -- it's just one thing after another.
NICK SCHIFRIN: In so many ways, Russia has taken a page from its own playbook and targeted Ukraine's most vulnerable.
This used to be a psychiatric institution, hit by four Russian rockets, one of at least eight hospitals in this city alone struck by Russia, part of what independent researchers call a nationwide campaign against Ukrainian medical facilities.
Physicians for Human Rights mapped every attack on a medical facility between February 24 and December 31.
They counted 707.
If you think this is new, you haven't been paying attention.
Russia has used the same tactics in Syria for eight years.
But now Russia is now committing a new crime.
These children might look happy for Russian propaganda cameras, but each is Ukrainian, stolen from their homeland and forcibly made Russian.
This is the reality.
Russians besieged Mariupol, and forced its children into Russia, including those of Yevhen Mezhevyi.
YEVHEN MEZHEVYI, Father (through translator): I put the children on the bus, hugged and kissed them.
CHILD (through translator): One man said he would be returned in seven years.
People said five or seven years.
CHILD (through translator): They asked me again, do you want to join a foster family or an orphanage?
NICK SCHIFRIN: They told their story in a "Vanity Fair" documentary for The Reckoning Project.
Nataliya Gumenyuk is the group's founding member.
NATALIYA GUMENYUK, The Reckoning Project: From some of the testimonies and also analytical reports and what we hear from the people, there is an attempt to indoctrinate those kids with the different policies, with the different ideas, and actually creating kind of a hatred and denial of the Ukrainian state.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Mezhevyi managed to travel to Moscow and escape with his children to Latvia.
The U.S. says Moscow's actions are taken at all levels of the Russian government, including the top.
Last week, Russian President Vladimir Putin met the presidential commissioner for children's rights in Russia, who said she -- quote -- "adopted" her own Ukrainian child.
NATALIYA GUMENYUK: I think Russia, in particularly, in previous wars in Syria, in Chechnya, they were acting with such an impunity, thinking that nobody would care.
In Ukraine, they made a mistake.
We do care.
We record.
We document.
There is the will of the people of the country to do something.
And that gives a hope that that -- the justice can be sir can prevail.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Ukraine wants to create an independent tribunal to pursue Russia's leadership.
But the U.S. has so far refused to support that, and instead prioritizes the International Criminal Court.
Accountability there will take years, while the Russian missiles keep falling.
The strike blew open a dozen homes and rained debris on the playground.
The same playground where 61-year-old Sergey Seydaliev's children used to play.
He stares at his now-destroyed home, where he lived with his parents and his family for the last 42 years.
There is so much torment here, but it's mixed with a tenacious will.
SERGEY SEYDALIEV, Resident of Pokrovsk, Ukraine (through translator): We lost all of our savings.
This is my whole life.
And now everything is gone.
Everything is gone.
I'm an older man.
But we will make it through.
Life does not stop here.
We will win, for sure, I have no doubt whatsoever.
NICK SCHIFRIN: After all the Russian crimes, most Ukrainians say the only justice would be victory.
For the "PBS NewsHour," I'm Nick Schifrin in Kramatorsk, Ukraine.
GEOFF BENNETT: In the day's other headlines: Parts of California were under blizzard and flood warnings today, as a vicious storm intensified across the Western U.S.
Forecasters warned up to five feet of snow could fall on the mountains near Los Angeles.
The weather caused dangerous whiteout conditions for drivers.
In Portland, Oregon, people were trapped on icy roads for hours.
ROBERT INSLEY, Truck Driver: Twelve, 13, 14 hours, the road opened up, and I got up to here, and it had -- and there was a big truck over here, and he couldn't get up the Hill.
So, I parked it here, and I got to wait for a tow truck.
That's the safest thing.
I have been up all night long.
GEOFF BENNETT: Farther east, about 650,000 people are still without power in Michigan after one of the worst ice storms there in decades.
The heavy snow and freezing rain are expected to linger from coast to coast into the weekend.
In Brazil, the death toll from heavy rain that has devastated coastal areas has risen to 54 people.
Cleanup efforts are under way after massive downpours caused landslides and flooding in the southeastern state of Sao Paulo last weekend.
Residents are reeling from the loss.
VALDEMIR, Flood Victim (through translator): All my houses were brought down.
The broken tiles and shingles fell on us, leaving us injured.
I called out to my mother, hoping she would answer, but all I heard were three cries from her and nothing else.
At that moment, I knew she was taken away from us forever.
GEOFF BENNETT: Rescuers are searching for dozens of people who are still missing before more rain moves in this weekend.
Back in this country, the Federal Reserve's preferred measure of inflation rose more than expected last month, triggering a Wall Street sell-off, as investors weighed the prospect of interest rates staying higher for longer.
The Dow Jones industrial average lost 337 points to close at 32817.
The Nasdaq fell 195 points.
And the S&P 500 shed 42.
First lady Jill Biden is giving the strongest signal yet that President Joe Biden will run for reelection.
The president has long said that it's his intention to run again, but has not yet made it official.
During an interview with the Associated Press during a trip to Kenya, the first lady said the president is gearing up for a race.
JILL BIDEN, Wife of Joe Biden: He says he's not done.
He's not finished what he started.
And that's what's important.
And I think look at all that Joe has done.
QUESTION: Is all that's left at this point is just to figure out a time and place for the announcement?
JILL BIDEN: Pretty much.
GEOFF BENNETT: Meantime, Vice President Kamala Harris met today with reproductive rights advocates and defended access to abortion pills.
She spoke out as a Texas lawsuit seeks to ban sales of the FDA-approved abortion pill mifepristone nationwide over concerns its safety review was flawed.
The vice president said its the latest effort to limit women's rights since Roe v. Wade was overturned last year.
KAMALA HARRIS, Vice President of the United States: We will continue to fight for the rights of American people to make decisions about their own bodies, free from government interference and free from partisan political obstructionist attacks.
This is not just an attack on women's fundamental freedoms.
It is an attack on the very foundations of our public health system.
GEOFF BENNETT: The meeting happened as 12 Democrat-led states sued the federal government today to expand access to mifepristone, challenging restrictions on its distribution.
And still to come on the "NewsHour": why House Speaker McCarthy is drawing criticism for giving FOX exclusive footage of the January 6 attack; David Brooks and Jonathan Capehart weigh in on the week's political headlines; and the Ukrainian Ballet uses dance to help their country's fight against Russia.
AMNA NAWAZ: In the nearly three weeks since deadly quakes hit Southern Turkey and Northern Syria, the focus has shifted from rescue to rehabilitation.
The task ahead is not only to reconstruct homes, but also to rebuild lives, especially for the youngest victims.
Special correspondent Jane Ferguson reports.
JANE FERGUSON: In the tent city of Gaziantep, life after the earthquakes is all but an endless struggle.
Hatice Demir is battling cancer and now homelessness.
Learning to live with the bare minimum.
HATICE DEMIR, Turkish Earthquake Survivor (through translator): I used to wake up in a warm room, but now I'm chasing gas stations, running around looking for a sink to wash up.
Our opportunities are gone.
Our self-confidence is gone.
JANE FERGUSON: Like her, a million Turks are now without a home.
Hundreds here stood in line in the cold for a shower.
The public swimming pool has been turned into a sanitation center.
Efforts to find the living under the rubble have ended, now a focus on the next stage, rebuilding.
Yasir Behrakci is picking up the pieces of his life.
YASIR BEHRAKCI, Turkish Earthquake Survivor (through translator): We cannot bring back the dead.
But, because we survived, we are trying to get out whatever is left.
We have to live.
We have no other choice.
TOM SMITH, Project HOPE: Luckily, that mind shift and work is getting started.
We are in Adiyaman, which, as you know, is 60 percent, 70 percent destroyed.
They are already clearing large plots of land to put containers on.
JANE FERGUSON: Tom Smith is an American air force veteran, volunteering in Turkey with Washington, D.C., based charity project hope.
TOM SMITH: The challenge is there.
When you talk about just rebuilding, it is not just, hey, here is the house that we are going to rebuild.
It is going to be, what is that intermediary step, which is basic housing units.
JANE FERGUSON: Smith and his team have been assessing the needs of those displaced by the earthquake.
TOM SMITH: The need for sanitation.
Everyone -- everyone loves that hot shower, the ability to wash their hands, go to a safe latrine and safe drinking water.
It is still cold here.
It's 20 degrees at night, 40 degrees during the day.
And people are living in tents.
JANE FERGUSON: And yet attempts to move on have been disrupted again by the heaving earth.
On Monday, another large quake in Antakya terrified already traumatized displaced families.
RAWAN HAMADEH, Project HOPE: This is what we call complex trauma, because, OK, the incident happened the first time, but now it is reoccurring.
We are -- we're currently experiencing aftershocks, and the people are -- continuously going through the trauma again and again.
JANE FERGUSON: Rawan Hamadeh is also with Project HOPE and provides psychological support to earthquake victims and rescue staff.
She says the last few weeks have been especially tough on the youngest here.
RAWAN HAMADEH: We hear stories about children going mute after the earthquake and not being able to talk or to express themselves in any way.
We are seeing, like, bed-wetting issues, of course, disturbances in sleep and eating patterns.
We are seeing children who are extremely attached to their mother.
They wouldn't leave their side or extreme isolation from others.
JANE FERGUSON: Volunteers are trying to bring joy back to their lives, an effort to let children be children.
Infants across the border in Northwest Syria are also in desperate need.
This clinic in the quake-hit Jindires is overrun with patients, but running out of medicines.
A U.N. delegation finally arrived here, over two weeks since the earthquakes.
DAVID ANTHONY CARDEN, United Nations: I'm shocked by the scale of the disaster.
I have never seen anything like it.
People need food.
They need shelter.
They need fresh water.
They need sanitation.
So, the needs are huge.
JANE FERGUSON: A day after the first wave of quakes, this family survived against all odds.
Mostafa El Sayed, his wife and three children were some of the few to make it out alive from Haram city, where 800 people died.
At that time, this moment of his little dollar's Elaf's rescue was a rare glimmer of hope in a battered Syria.
The "NewsHour" caught up with them two weeks later.
ZUHAIR EL SAYED, Syrian Earthquake Survivor (through translator): I'm 5 right now, right?
Five levels fell on top of us.
We were calling out: "Civil defense, please help us.
We are going to die."
There was a man who heard us.
They said they are going to rescue us in the morning.
I was like, whoa.
I was sleeping, sleeping, sleeping, and then I knew they were coming to take us out.
ELAF EL SAYED, Syrian Earthquake Survivor (through translator): We were sleeping, and there was a small earthquake.
And then there was another one.
And the rocks fell on top of us.
There was dirt in my ear.
And then the civil defense came, and they rescued us,and they took us to the hospital, and then they took us to grandpa's house.
JANE FERGUSON: Elaf and thousands of Syrian and Turkish kids like her have escaped with their lives.
The quality of those lives now depends on an unprecedented, massive operation to repair and rebuild.
For the "PBS NewsHour," I'm Jane Ferguson.
GEOFF BENNETT: This week marked the anniversary of the assassination of Malcolm X.
Since that day 58 years ago, there have been many difficult and painful questions about who may have been involved in his murder and what led to it.
This week, Malcolm X's family took new action, announcing their intent to sue several federal and local government agencies for allegedly concealing evidence about what happened.
ILYASAH SHABAZZ, Daughter of Malcolm X: We want justice served for our father.
GEOFF BENNETT: Malcolm X's daughter Ilyasah Shabazz still searching for answers decades after his assassination.
At a press conference this week, Shabazz, surrounded by family and civil rights attorney Ben Crump, announced plans to file a $100 million wrongful death lawsuit against the NYPD, the CIA, FBI and other government agencies.
ILYASAH SHABAZZ: For years, our family has fought for the truth to come to light concerning his murder.
And we'd like our father to receive the justice that he deserves.
GEOFF BENNETT: They allege a conspiracy in connection with Malcolm X's murder and a subsequent cover-up of evidence.
ILYASAH SHABAZZ: The truth about the circumstances leading to the death of our father is important, not only to his family, but to many followers, many admirers, many who look to him for guidance, for love.
GEOFF BENNETT: On February 21, 1965, Malcolm X was killed in a hail of bullets just as he was about to give a speech in the Audubon Ballroom in Harlem, as his pregnant wife and children ducked for safety.
He was 39 years old.
Three men were arrested and convicted of the crime.
In November 2021, after decades of doubts surrounding the case, and following the release of the Netflix documentary "Who Killed Malcolm X?"
the Manhattan district attorney reopened the case.
Two men who were convicted of murdering Malcolm X in 1966 were exonerated after serving decades in prison.
And the district attorney admitted that the FBI and NYPD at the time withheld evidence.
BENJAMIN CRUMP, Attorney for Family of Malcolm X: The New York Police Department, the FBI, the district attorney of New York had factual evidence, exculpatory evidence that they fraudulently concealed from the men who were wrongfully convicted for the assassination of Malcolm X.
And they also fraudulently concealed that information, most importantly, from the family of Malcolm X. GEOFF BENNETT: The FBI, CIA and NYPD did not respond to the "NewsHour"'s requests for comments.
The lawsuit could help put to rest decades of controversy and conspiracy theories that have swirled in the more than 50 years since his assassination.
Leading Malcolm X historian Abdur-Rahman Muhammad sees the suit as the culmination of years of work investigating the assassination.
ABDUR-RAHMAN MUHAMMAD, Historian: I'm extremely gratified and really had no way of knowing going into this that it would culminate in such a spectacular victory.
I think it's unprecedented in U.S. history that that's ever happened.
And I'm extremely grateful and gratified to have lived long enough to see this day.
GEOFF BENNETT: As for Malcolm X's family, they say they want their father to receive the justice he deserves.
Some Republicans are once again relitigating what happened at the U.S. Capitol on January 6, with House Speaker Kevin McCarthy sharing key video footage of the Capitol attack with a star FOX personality.
Lisa Desjardins brings us up to speed about how it happened and what Tucker Carlson hopes to find in the footage.
TUCKER CARLSON, FOX News Anchor: And why are they still hiding thousands of hours of surveillance footage from within the Capitol?
LISA DESJARDINS: For months, he asked for access.
TUCKER CARLSON: You can't know whether the Capitol surveillance videos pan, tilt or zoom.
LISA DESJARDINS: And now Tucker Carlson has it.
This week, Republican Speaker Kevin McCarthy granted the FOX News host access to 44,000 hours of security footage from Capitol grounds on January 6.
Carlson controls a prime-time hour on the most watched cable network.
TUCKER CARLSON: On the basis of a wholly created myth about what happened that day.
LISA DESJARDINS: And has been a megaphone for baseless conspiracy theories that deflect blame from former President Trump, including the idea that rioters on January 6 were actually victims of a government false flag plot.
He sees surveillance footage as possible evidence.
TUCKER CARLSON: Our producers, some of our smartest producers, have been there looking at this stuff and trying to figure out what it means and how it contradicts or not the story that we have been told for more than two years.
We think already that, in some ways, it does contradict that story.
LISA DESJARDINS: Carlson's words over the last two years reveal the narrative he wants.
TUCKER CARLSON: How many law enforcement agents actively helped January 6 protesters enter the building that day?
Some of them definitely did.
We know that for a fact.
Ray Epps was standing in exactly the same place that a lot of people who went to jail were standing, but he wasn't charged.
His name was taken off the FBI's most wanted list.
Why is that?
LISA DESJARDINS: But evidence shows that Ray Epps, an Arizona man who was at the Capitol, bank Capitol, was telling protesters to calm down.
And Carlson's allegation that Epps was working for the FBI has been debunked.
PROTESTER: USA!
USA!
LISA DESJARDINS: Overall, there is no evidence of undercover law enforcement instigating the rioters.
REP. KEVIN MCCARTHY (R-CA): Yes, I think the public should see what happened on the... LISA DESJARDINS: In granting FOX assets access, McCarthy keeps a promise to hard-line members in his conference from negotiations boosted by Carlson himself.
TUCKER CARLSON: If Kevin McCarthy wants to be the speaker, he is going to have to do things he would never do otherwise.
LISA DESJARDINS: McCarthy told The New York Times this week that the tapes belong to the public and he wants sunshine on them.
But Carlson is not a neutral arbiter.
He has condemned violence, but also defended the motivations behind it.
TUCKER CARLSON: How, for example, did senile hermit Joe Biden get 15 million more votes than his former boss, rock star crowd-surfer Barack Obama?
LISA DESJARDINS: Despite raising conspiracies, recent court filings show Carlson and other top FOX stars didn't believe some of the pro-Trump claims.
In text messages, Carlson wrote about a one-time Trump adviser: "Sidney Powell is lying, by the way.
I caught her.
It's insane."
Carlson's not the first to access these tapes.
They have already been reviewed by the House Select Committee Investigating January 6 last Congress.
Republicans accuse the group of cherry-picking those clips, and FOX did not air much of its hearings.
TUCKER CARLSON: They are lying, and we are not going to help them do it.
LISA DESJARDINS: Back at the Capitol, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer issued a scathing statement, accusing McCarthy of "exposing the Capitol Complex to one of the worst security risks since 9/11."
McCarthy says he intends to grant others access to the video in the future.
But, until then, it remains an exclusive deal between the leading Republican in Congress and the party's prime-time star.
For the "PBS NewsHour," I'm Lisa Desjardins.
AMNA NAWAZ: For insights into the larger implications of Tucker Carlson's access to that January 6 footage and what the year of war in Ukraine can tell us about the future direction of that conflict and the world, we turn now to the analysis of Brooks and Capehart.
That is New York Times columnist David Brooks, and Jonathan Capehart, associate editor for The Washington Post.
Good to see you both.
JONATHAN CAPEHART: Hey, Amna.
DAVID BROOKS: Good to see you.
AMNA NAWAZ: Let's pick up where Lisa left off there, Jonathan.
This idea Speaker McCarthy has handed over these thousands of hours of security footage to Tucker Carlson, there are those who argue, just let everyone see everything and make up their own minds about it.
Is there validity to that?
JONATHAN CAPEHART: Well, sure, simply because the speaker has given all of this footage to Tucker Carlson.
If you're going to give it to him, you should give it to MSNBC, CNN.
Give it to everyone.
Give it to PBS.
Give it to everyone so that they can look at it.
But you know what?
I don't need to see 44,000 hours' worth of footage.
I watched our government being attacked by supporters of the former president live on television in real time over several hours.
I don't know what Tucker Carlson is going to do with this video, with the footage and how he's going to present it on his show.
But whatever it is, and however he does it, and whenever he does, it will be a disservice to his viewers.
It will be a disservice to this country.
AMNA NAWAZ: David, we don't know what he's going to do with it.
I am baffled, though, by this idea that it seemed like for a long time Republicans wanted to get as far away from January 6 as they could.
This feels like they're resurrecting it now.
Why talk about it more?
(CROSSTALK) DAVID BROOKS: Marjorie Taylor Greene was ecstatic over this.
So this is clearly what they wanted and what they wanted in exchange for voting for Kevin McCarthy.
I guess their argument is that the people on the committee were not exactly friends to Donald Trump, and so somebody who is more friendly to Donald Trump should have a whack at it.
And so you want to pick the Edward R. Murrow of our day, Tucker Carlson.
(LAUGHTER) DAVID BROOKS: And so think... (CROSSTALK) AMNA NAWAZ: Sarcasm duly noted, I just want to say.
JONATHAN CAPEHART: I will laugh.
(LAUGHTER) DAVID BROOKS: I think, in general, opening it up as long as they protect the procedures of this -- of the Capitol security, and as long as you don't release those opening up widely, giving anything -- any public official giving everything to one news organization, that's just bizarre and against the rules of what we do.
If you give it to one news organization, it should be a dump off the record, but just doing it out in front of the day, it's just - - it's not done.
You give it to the public.
AMNA NAWAZ: Are you worried about how they will use it?
DAVID BROOKS: Yes, I worry about everything Tucker touches these days.
I used to work for him for a long time.
But I think the conspiracy theories are out there.
There may be more conspiracy theories.
It's hard to imagine them building another mountain of nonsense on top of the existing mountain of nonsense that comes out.
AMNA NAWAZ: We will be waiting and watching and I'm sure talking about it some more.
That's one of the issues dividing a lot of Americans right now.
We also asked in our latest "PBS NewsHour"/Marist/NPR poll a number of other issues that Americans have varying opinions on.
We asked both of you what stood out to you from that poll.
And you actually pointed to the same question that I want to highlight here, which is on the question of U.S. support for Ukraine.
When you take a look at those numbers, we asked people what they thought about the level of support.
About 42 percent of people said we're providing the right amount of support.
But this number, the third of people who said we're providing too much support, did stick out to me.
And if you dig down deeper into that, there is a partisan divide as well.
That's Republicans in that group overwhelmingly feel that there is too much support from the U.S. going to Ukraine.
Why did that stand out to you, Jonathan.
JONATHAN CAPEHART: Well, it stood out to me because of what we have been hearing from the Republican House majority, Marjorie Taylor Greene and others, talking, and, even before he became speaker, Kevin McCarthy, talking about, well, maybe we're giving too much support, we're sending too much money to Ukraine.
So the fact that 47 percent of Republicans say that it's too much, and 54 percent of Trump voters say that it's too much, to my mind, says that, after the president releases his budget on March 9, or when the president goes back to Congress for more funding, that we will then start to see this friction that we have only been talking about in theory play out in public.
And I think, from the administration's perspective, that kind of daylight is not helpful, because what the president has been banking on is a unified front... AMNA NAWAZ: Right.
JONATHAN CAPEHART: ... both within the American government for Ukraine, but then among the alliance.
And if that frays within the United States, then the fear is that that fraying could also impact the alliance as well.
AMNA NAWAZ: What do those numbers say to you?
DAVID BROOKS: Yes, I mean, it's fascinating on the Republican side.
Our -- there was a Pew poll that had similar numbers to ours, which had 40 percent of Republicans saying we're giving too much and 41 percent said we're giving the right amount or should give more.
And you're beginning to see this play out in the Republican field.
And so you have got -- you have got, well, Donald Trump.
You have got President Tucker Carlson and other major Republican figures saying, too much, too much, too much.
And then you have got, meanwhile, Tom Cotton, Tim Scott, Nikki Haley all saying, not enough, not enough, not enough, and so radically different policy agendas.
And, this week, Ron DeSantis went on "FOX & Friends," and he sort of danced between the two, sort of edging a little toward -- but what you're seeing is a party bitterly divided over something of real substance.
And I think the primaries will just reveal that over and over again.
AMNA NAWAZ: It's striking too, as we mark one year since the Russian invasion of Ukraine this week, a war, we should remind people, many thought would not last but a matter of days, we actually went back and saw what both of you had to say a year ago.
DAVID BROOKS: Oh.
AMNA NAWAZ: Here's just a snippet of what you were saying a year ago when it came to the war in Ukraine.
DAVID BROOKS: We were blessed to live for many years, probably all of our lives so far, in this era of rules.
We may be ending that era and reentering an era of great power rivalries, such as we saw in the 17th century and the 18th century and the 16th century and the 15th century.
JONATHAN CAPEHART: We are seeing right there the battle between democracy and autocracy, and having democracy win is not assured, especially because democracy here in the United States is the weakest it's been in memory.
AMNA NAWAZ: First of all, I will say it's nice to have you both here in person, rather than your home studios.
(LAUGHTER) AMNA NAWAZ: But, Jonathan, do you still see it the same way?
Does democracy stand a better chance today than it did a year ago?
JONATHAN CAPEHART: Yes.
Arguably, yes, because, at that moment, we weren't quite sure whether Ukraine, whether President Zelenskyy, who no one had any kind of expectation of him or of the country, but we were disabused of that within -- within days.
And the fact that we are here entering year two is extraordinary.
It says a lot about President Zelenskyy.
It says a lot about the Ukrainian -- it says more about the Ukrainian people, their willingness to fight for their -- for their country, men and women, anyone.
Remember those early pictures of people learning how to shoot guns because they were going to defend themselves against the Russians.
But that fight between democracy and autocracy is still there.
And we could be facing a situation where that battle is -- will become more fraught as Russia gets more desperate.
AMNA NAWAZ: David, what about you?
Are we deeper into this new era, as you described it?
DAVID BROOKS: Yes, we are.
I mean, it's hard to overestimate how big a deal this war has been.
When you think about the events of the last year, it's been -- it's been earthshaking, literally earthshaking.
And, first, the humanitarian crisis has just been overwhelming.
But, second, the Western alliance has been reformed.
American influence in the world has expanded.
Military strategy has been utterly changed by the war.
There's been a global decoupling of our economies.
Energy flows have radically changed.
Russia and China have come together.
These are all sort of big events that have all been set off by this war.
And I think, basically, the contradictions have become focused.
We in the West, including Japan and other countries, but the democracy-loving countries, the countries who want to maintain the liberal world over, have been strengthened and hardened by the people of Ukraine.
But, even this week, the Russians and the Chinese are getting closer together.
And so it really looks like a global power struggle between people who want to respect human dignity and people who not so much.
AMNA NAWAZ: Could China's entry into this war, as we have seen U.S. officials warning against the provision of lethal aid, could that change the direction of the war?
DAVID BROOKS: For sure.
And one thinks of Korea, the Korean War.
And so that was a war started by a Russian dictator.
They had some success, but they thought the U.S. would never get involved, and they thought it would be an easy victory.
It turned not to be.
The U.S. got involved.
They pushed them back.
They got the Chinese involved.
The Chinese altered the course of the war for a little while.
And then we pushed them back.
And it was a deadlock.
And we signed an armistice that people thought was temporary.
Turned out to be not temporary.
And so, as people look to the future of Ukraine and the possibility of a negotiated settlement, I think a lot of will determine what happens this spring.
And then we can start to think about, how can we get through a negotiated peace?
But, right now, we're not there.
And I'm sure Putin is hoping China will fundamentally alter the logic of the war.
AMNA NAWAZ: Jonathan, Americans have felt the effects of the war to some degree, right, certainly the reshaping of the global energy market, the knock-on effects of all of that, and bearing witness through the reporting, like our colleague Nick Schifrin has been doing out there.
JONATHAN CAPEHART: Right.
AMNA NAWAZ: But it's not necessarily the same, certainly for Ukrainians and even for Europeans, who are feeling it more immediately.
Do you think, the longer this goes on, we do see a decline in support?
And what does that mean for the future of the war?
JONATHAN CAPEHART: Yes, unfortunately, because of our oceans, and most of the American people have no real skin in the game, it's easy for us to go from the euphoria of cheering on an underdog to, like, yes, this has been going on while, I'm going to go on and think about other things.
But we, in this business, we cannot -- we cannot be a part of that process.
We have to keep telling the stories.
We have to keep doing the reporting.
We have to keep explaining why this is important.
This just isn't because Russia invaded Ukraine.
There are bigger issues here that David -- that David pointed out.
And if China does provide lethal aid to Russia, how does the Biden administration hold back on those F-16s that President Zelenskyy has been asking for?
If this truly is a battle between democracy and autocracy, at some point, democracy will have to -- will have to rear up on his hind legs and smack down autocracy.
And we could see that after we see what happens with the spring offensive.
AMNA NAWAZ: Do you see this stretching another year, David?
DAVID BROOKS: For sure, yes.
But I see us holding still and hold -- the West holding firm.
I was in Dublin.
And I'm waiting in my -- to get my passport checked.
There's a loud Irish lady running the line.
And she says: "Clear way.
Clear way."
And she's got this Ukrainian family at the end of the line.
She said: "These people are going first.
They're going first.
These are the most important people in the world right now."
And we all bow and shake hands.
And so that Irish lady, her -- on her own, will help the Western alliance stay intact.
(LAUGHTER) AMNA NAWAZ: I think we can all buy into that idea.
David Brooks, Jonathan Capehart, thank you so much.
JONATHAN CAPEHART: Thanks, Amna.
DAVID BROOKS: Thank you.
GEOFF BENNETT: During the past 12 months of war, Ukrainians have demonstrated their courage and resilience in countless ways.
One group of artists is responding the best way they know how, through dance, bringing their work and their stories to world stages.
Jeffrey Brown profiles the United Ukrainian Ballet for our arts and culture series, Canvas.
JEFFREY BROWN: "Giselle," one of the most beloved ballets in the classical repertoire, gorgeous music and movement, a story of romance and loss.
But this production performed recently at Washington, D.C.'s Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, had its own added story, one dancers like Oleksii Kniazkov brought to the stage.
OLEKSII KNIAZKOV, United Ukrainian Ballet: All dancers or maybe all of Ukrainians have this floating on the waves all the time with the emotions with everything.
We don't know how it will end.
We don't know, will we have our homes when we will come back?
JEFFREY BROWN: Before the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Kniazkov, 30, was a principal dancer with the Kharkiv National Opera and Ballet in Ukraine's second largest city.
The war put a stop to his career, as to so much else.
More important, it has threatened his homeland and the lives of his loved ones, most of whom remain in Donetsk, where he grew up.
Now he is of more than 60 professional dancers from theaters throughout Ukraine living in exile in The Hague in the Netherlands, joined as the United Ukrainian Ballet.
WOMAN: My soul is, like, broken.
JEFFREY BROWN: Several of them danced amid the rubble at home to highlight the mission of the new group.
WOMAN: The only thing that could save me, it's dancing.
JEFFREY BROWN: Kniazkov and the other male dancers were given special permission by the government to leave Ukraine to take part in this project, an acknowledgement of their importance as cultural ambassadors.
OLEKSII KNIAZKOV: People see us, like, bones and, like, blood.
JEFFREY BROWN: Like real flesh-and-blood human beings.
(CROSSTALK) OLEKSII KNIAZKOV: Yes, not on screen on some - - when they watch news.
But when you see these real people on the stage, you can maybe understand them, feel their emotions and in some way united with them, some way connect with them.
JEFFREY BROWN: Twenty-year-old Vladyslava Ihnatenko grew up in Kharkiv, where her family remains.
She had just begun her dancing career in Odessa when the war broke out.
VLADYSLAVA IHNATENKO, United Ukrainian Ballet: We are really trying to help each other, and we understand each other more than everyone else at this time.
So I, think its really powerful community for us to share our, Well, emotions and to help each other to work on the same project.
JEFFREY BROWN: Sharing emotions.
Everybody has difficult, painful emotions now.
VLADYSLAVA IHNATENKO: Yes, that's right.
But, also, it's really nice when people, after a performance, think about how to help our country or maybe check on something what happened there much more, to donate, to help, to ask Ukrainian people how it is.
It's really nice to communicate like this.
IGONE DE JONGH, Artistic Director, United Ukrainian Ballet: When we had this idea, we never thought it would be this, it would never become this big.
JEFFREY BROWN: The United Ukrainian Ballet was begun last year by Dutch ballerina Igone de Jongh, who serves as the company's artistic director.
WOMAN: This is my room.
JEFFREY BROWN: She helped find lodging and studio space in The Hague and gradually brought more dancers into the fold.
This is unlike anything she or the dancers have ever done.
For one thing, ballet requires enormous discipline and focus.
But these dancers necessarily have their minds on their families and friends back home.
IGONE DE JONGH: I try to have conversations with them where I said to them, maybe just 10 minutes or just 15 minutes during class, just focus on you, focus on what you are doing with your body and give yourself a little break.
It's, of course, a very difficult question to ask.
But after a few months, I could feel that they were getting a little bit more comfortable and a little bit more at ease with just dancing.
JEFFREY BROWN: There is a psychology to this project that you probably have never experienced yourself.
IGONE DE JONGH: No, no.
And I don't think there's a rule book for it.
ALEXEI RATMANSKY, Guest Choreographer, United Ukrainian Ballet: If you have any sense of fairness, of what's right, what's wrong, I think that's the only choice.
Ukraine is fighting for freedom and democracy.
JEFFREY BROWN: The biggest name involved with the United Ukrainian Ballet is Alexei Ratmansky, a one-time director of Moscow's famed Bolshoi Ballet, today one of the world's most renowned choreographers.
The company is performing his version of "Giselle," which restores some of the movement and other features of the original 19th century French ballet.
And he brings his own unusually personal story to this project.
His mother is Russian, his father Ukrainian.
He was born in Leningrad, now St. Petersburg, Russia, but raised in Kyiv.
On the day Russia attacked Ukraine, he was actually in Moscow working with the Bolshoi, and his world changed too.
ALEXEI RATMANSKY: When my wife called me from New York saying Kyiv is bound, it was 5:00 a.m.
I didn't have any choice.
I just left right away.
I grabbed my team, and I felt that this door is shut for me, because I can't split.
I can't sit on two chairs.
I have to make a decision.
JEFFREY BROWN: And the decision is Ukrainian identity and the country must be supported?
ALEXEI RATMANSKY: Right, right.
JEFFREY BROWN: That support is now evident in his work with the United Ukrainian Ballet, also in his public criticism of prominent Russian artists for not speaking out.
He understands why some Russians, fearing for their families, might stay silent, but, he says: ALEXEI RATMANSKY: You can't pretend that nothing is going on.
You can't say, life continues, we are happy, we are dancing.
You know, there is something that just -- it doesn't work that way.
You are selling yourself to the wrong person.
You are on the wrong side.
JEFFREY BROWN: For the Ukrainian dancers, of course, there is also no question of the right and wrong side.
And, for them, being able to dance is part of their identity, stripped away by the war.
OLEKSII KNIAZKOV: In some way, when I came on stage in Netherlands the first time, it was almost half-year past after beginning of the war.
It was in August.
I felt that my life came back to me, that I begin to live again.
JEFFREY BROWN: Are you worried that the rest of the world isn't paying as much attention anymore?
VLADYSLAVA IHNATENKO: Sometimes, it's doubts about it.
But then you came to another country, and you see people keep interested in news about Ukraine.
So, our mission to make it... OLEKSII KNIAZKOV: Remind them.
VLADYSLAVA IHNATENKO: Yes, more people to keep it in mind.
JEFFREY BROWN: The group ends each performance by singing the Ukrainian national anthem.
(CHEERING AND APPLAUSE) JEFFREY BROWN: For the "PBS NewsHour," I am Jeffrey Brown at Washington, D.C.'s Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts.
AMNA NAWAZ: And you can watch more of our stories on the war in Ukraine over the past year on our YouTube page.
GEOFF BENNETT: Tune into "Washington Week" tonight for more analysis of the war in Ukraine and President Biden's recent trip to Kyiv.
AMNA NAWAZ: And watch "PBS News Weekend" to hear the story of Ed Dwight, the Air Force pilot who helped pave the way for NASA's Black astronauts.
In the meantime, that is the "NewsHour."
I'm Amna Nawaz.
GEOFF BENNETT: And I'm Geoff Bennett.
Thanks for joining us, and have a great weekend.
Brooks and Capehart on Fox's access to Jan. 6 video
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 2/24/2023 | 11m 28s | Brooks and Capehart on Tucker Carlson's access to Jan. 6 video, war in Ukraine (11m 28s)
Earthquake recovery hampered by sheer scale of destruction
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 2/24/2023 | 5m 31s | Earthquake recovery hampered by sheer scale of destruction in Turkey and Syria (5m 31s)
Lawsuit may provide answers about Malcolm X's assassination
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 2/24/2023 | 3m 49s | New lawsuit may help provide answers about Malcolm X's assassination (3m 49s)
McCarthy criticized for giving Carlson Jan. 6 videos
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 2/24/2023 | 3m 45s | McCarthy drawing criticism for giving Carlson exclusive access to video of Jan. 6 attack (3m 45s)
Ukrainian ballet dancers serve as cultural ambassadors
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 2/24/2023 | 7m 57s | Ukrainian ballet dancers in exile serve as cultural ambassadors as war rages on at home (7m 57s)
Zelenskyy delivers call for Ukrainians to stay resilient
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 2/24/2023 | 14m 54s | Zelenskyy delivers call for Ukrainians to stay resilient a year into Russia's invasion (14m 54s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Major corporate funding for the PBS News Hour is provided by BDO, BNSF, Consumer Cellular, American Cruise Lines, and Raymond James. Funding for the PBS NewsHour Weekend is provided by...